Who Helps Us Die
I really had no idea how fearful we are of death until I learned that the two groups of professionals we expect to have the most to offer on the topic of death and dying actually have the least-doctors and ministers.
What follows is a portion of an email from a recent graduate of seminary school:
“Its amazing you are writing a book about dying after having such a close relationship with someone who passed away. I bet you have a lot to say. I am so with you, in that our culture has an unhealthy relationship with death. A lot of people get nervous about what they don’t understand and can’t control- especially ministers and priests I imagine, even though they deal with it all the time. This summer I worked as a chaplain at a hospital and worked with people as they were healing and also as they were dying and it was an incredible experience- difficult and so enlightening.
One of my favorite passages about a medium in the bible is 1 Samuel 28. Its the “witch” or “medium” of Endor. Saul, who had previously kicked out all the wizards & mediums from the area, ends up seeking a medium out to contact Samuel. And it works. The thing is, even though psychics were “outlawed” the person who expelled them in the first place knows EXACTLY where to go to find one. Its threatening to people in this story because it works. And also, I imagine, because the witch is a woman. Women’s power is frightening for people- then and now.
What we are taught about death and dying and grieving here is that it varies. There is no one way to grieve or to die or to council somebody. The main thing though, is to BE with the person 100% in what they are experiencing. So if you are experiencing that it would be healing for you to go to a psychic, you should do it. And hopefully your clergy person would support you. I totally believe in all that stuff, and think that going to a psychic is totally valid and fits very nicely into Christianity.”
None of the other men and woman of the cloth had anything to say about dying that you couldnt learn at a Christian funeral. At first I was mad, but then I realized it just confirmed what I thought -that regardless of our line of work-we all end up on the finish line fearful and unprepared.
Doctors are even more unprepared to face death, be it their own or the death of a patient. Some of that may have to do with the fact that their first encounter with a dead body is a cadaver. Here are some interesting facts on death and doctors:
How a doctor relates to death is determined, in part, by the speciality they enter. Death to a
• Most doctors see death as a defeat of what they are trying to accomplish
• One study indicated about 25% of doctors avoid the fatally ill.
• Only one-half are willing to tell a patient they are dying. Surveys, in class and National surveys, indicate about 90% of people want to know the truth if they have a terminal disease.
• 66% of doctors favor not telling the patient they are dying. Excuses for this kept secret include, “No one can predict that you are dying,” and if you are told, “you are liable to give up hope and possibly commit suicide.”
• Physicians have been found by survey to be more afraid of death than normal non-medical healthy people.
• Medical students receive very little training do you get in medical school on the subject of death.
Here are some other random musings:
On cadavers
“We’ve had fat fights. We were not blatantly disrespectful but the cadaver was dead and didn’t know what is going on.”
On the death of a loved one
How would you react if the terminally ill patient was a member of your family?
A. I don’t know and don’t like to think about it.
Written
on February 15, 2011